Tonight is the English-language federal leaders’ debate—and all eyes are on Mark Carney, the frontrunner trying to hold onto his lead.
But for anyone hoping to better understand the man who could be prime minister—or the record of the party he’s trying to rehabilitate—the debate is bound to disappoint. These events rarely deliver real accountability or a meaningful clash of ideas. Instead of thoughtful policy proposals, we get canned soundbites; instead of clarity, spin.
That’s why this edition of The Breach Election Files is doing what the debate likely won’t: unpacking Carney’s record and exposing a decade of Liberal rule that postured progressive while delivering mostly for the wealthy.
Who is Mark Carney, really?
Mark Carney is promising the steady hand of an expert and outsider. But behind his slick ‘pragmatism’ pitch is the same old austerity agenda that created the crises of today.
If elected, he promises to fulfill Bay Street’s wishlist: more cuts to spending, pipelines, and corporate handouts. And he’ll take the Liberal party further right.
➡️ READ: Mark Carney says he’s a pragmatic outsider—but he’s a banker selling yesterday’s failed ideas
🎧 LISTEN: The ‘tepid Liberal centrism’ of Mark Carney
🔎 GO DEEPER: Mark Carney wants you to believe in the free market
10 years of Liberal faux progressivism
Over his 10 years in office, Justin Trudeau mastered the art of changeless change. His government seduced progressive voters by appearing to disrupt business-as-usual, while serving the elite by simultaneously defending wealth and power.
📽️ WATCH: Justin Trudeau’s secret playbook
🎧 LISTEN: The sun sets on Justin Trudeau’s faux progressivism
Liberals ❤️ Big Oil
The Trudeau government promised climate leadership—but behind the scenes, it gave Big Oil a seat at the table, massive handouts, and backroom influence.
And how can we forget: our climate leader bought a pipeline. Its cost has ballooned to $50 billion (every few months it seems to go higher!).
➡️ READ: Oil lobby, Trudeau government formed secretive committee during pandemic
➡️ READ: Oil industry lobbied Trudeau government more than Harper Conservatives
🔎 GO DEEPER: How Trudeau learned to stop worrying and love the Alberta carbon bomb
Hawks at heart
From backing Israel’s war on Gaza to arming Saudi Arabia’s dictatorship and building new military bases overseas, the Liberals have continued to take Canada into a more aggressive role and deepened the country’s military alliance with the U.S.
📽️ WATCH: Why Canada is one of Israel’s most extreme defenders
📽️ WATCH: How Canada helps build Israel’s fighter jets
📽️ WATCH: Canada has voted against Palestine 150 times at UN in past decade
➡️ READ: Canada denounces ‘autocratic regimes’ while purchasing planes from Saudis
➡️ READ: Canada building global network of military bases in aggressive shift
🔎 GO DEEPER: Document reveals Canada’s undisclosed motives for arming Saudi Arabia
Reconciliation spectacle
Trudeau’s Liberals made big promises on reconciliation. But behind the land acknowledgements and tearful apologies, they upheld and advanced the same colonial policies as their predecessors. Their so-called reconciliation era gave cover to continued land theft, corporate extraction, and militarized violence against Indigenous land defenders—making the fight for Indigenous rights and sovereignty even harder.
🎧 LISTEN: The end of the reconciliation era?
➡️ READ: RCMP still clearing Indigenous lands for corporate interests
➡️ READ: Indigenous communities fight Canada’s ‘holy shit’ fix for tar sands wastewater
➡️ READ: The RCMP suppresses honest reporting about colonialism
🔎 GO DEEPER: Canada’s Irreconciliables
📽️ WATCH: Canada, it’s time for Land Back
Scapegoating migrants
While making a show of welcoming immigrants, Liberals ramped up deportations, allowed the exploitation of international students and workers to spiral, and handed corporations a cheap, precarious labour force.
📽️ WATCH: 6 ways Justin Trudeau is misleading Canadians about immigration
🔎 GO DEEPER: Liberals and Tories perfected the exploitation of migrants for big business
➡️ READ: Canada’s open secret: International students are here to be exploited
➡️ READ: Canada deporting highest level of migrants in a decade, despite promises to let more stay
Talking left, serving right
The Liberals talked tough on corporations and made promises to bring down the cost of living. But from housing to groceries to prescription drugs, their record tells another story: one of protecting profits while millions struggled to get by.
➡️ READ: Canada’s class war pantomime
➡️ READ: Minister stalled lower drug prices—then officials tried to keep it secret
🔎 GO DEEPER: After pharma lobbying, minister intervened to suspend drug-price reform
🔎 GO DEEPER: Grocery giants paid for friendly Liberal, Tory policy with decades of donations
➡️ READ: Canada’s blood plasma collection to be sold off to foreign pharma giant
📽️ WATCH: Liberals and Tories demolished Canada’s legacy of social housing
🔎 GO DEEPER: Liberal Housing Minister ‘wining and dining’ B.C.’s biggest real estate CEOs
That’s it for this week’s edition of The Breach Election Files.
As always, you can find more election analysis on our podcast. You can get The Breach Show on Apple, Spotify, Iheartradio, Google, or your favourite service.
If you don’t already, you can also subscribe to our channel on Youtube for video explainers, streeters, and interviews.
Speaking of Youtube, mark your calendars for our live election night coverage on Monday April 28th! We’ll have live guests and analysis you won’t find anywhere else—and don’t worry, we’ll have that official ticker to keep you posted on live results too.
Don’t miss it!
‘We need an outlet, a source of information that is credible, that is progressive, that we can cling to and believe in’
David Suzuki
Want to support journalism you can believe in? Become a sustainer today.
